Dexter: Original Sin – A Thrilling Start to a Promising Prequel

E NEWS: Paramount+ premiered the highly anticipated pilot episode of Dexter: Original Sin, and I must admit, I approached it with a mix of excitement and skepticism. How could any prequel live up to the legacy of the original series, especially with a new cast stepping into such iconic roles? To my surprise, the show delivered a gripping and nostalgic opening, marking a promising start to the latest chapter in the Dexter universe.

One of the standout moments for longtime fans was the return of the iconic Dexter opening intro. This much-missed sequence was glaringly absent in New Blood, and its reappearance immediately set the tone for the series, reminding us what makes Dexter truly Dexter.

Patrick Gibson Shines as a Young Dexter Morgan

Patrick Gibson steps into the shoes of a young Dexter Morgan, and while no one can fully replicate Michael C. Hall’s unparalleled performance, Gibson captures the essence of Dexter with surprising close accuracy. From his piercing gazes to his measured speech, Gibson brings the right mix of charm and menace, paying homage to the original actor while adding his own spin to the character. As a prequel, it’s less about comparison and more about evolution, and Gibson’s portrayal makes it clear he understands the weight of the role.

A Familiar Formula Returns

Clyde Phillips, the mastermind behind the original series, brings back the familiar balance of Dexter’s dual life. The pilot reintroduces us to Dexter’s constant struggle to maintain a facade of normalcy while grappling with his “dark passenger.” A great example is when Dexter misses his sister Debra’s (played by Molly Brown) volleyball game because he’s hunting the “Angel of Death,” a medical professional secretly harming patients. This storyline echoes the show’s classic themes of morality, guilt, and familial bonds.

The dynamic between young Dexter and Harry Morgan (Christian Slater) is another highlight. Harry’s guiding presence and strict moral code shaped Dexter into the killer we know, and Slater’s performance captures the complex relationship between father and son.

Debra and Supporting Cast Shine

Molly Brown’s portrayal of Debra Morgan stays true to the character’s core. Her unwavering support for Dexter, despite his flaws, feels authentic and mirrors the original series’ sibling dynamic. This is beautifully illustrated during Dexter’s high school graduation, where Deb’s presence signifies the deep bond they share.

The prequel also introduces young versions of other beloved characters. Alex Shimizu nails Vincent Masuka’s trademark laugh and quirky personality, while the actor playing Angel Batista (James Martinez) effortlessly channels the charm and look of the original character, complete with his signature fedora. Seeing them in the original Miami Metro Police Department set adds a layer of nostalgia.

A Promising Start for Fans

Without diving too deep into spoilers, Dexter: Original Sin captures the spirit of the original while carving out its own identity. The show’s attention to detail—from character mannerisms to set design—is a treat for fans. The mix of suspense, dark humor, and moral ambiguity feels right at home in the Dexter universe.

If this pilot is any indication, the prequel is setting the stage for an exciting exploration of Dexter’s formative years. With the announcement of Dexter: Resurrection slated for summer 2025, the franchise’s future looks brighter than ever.

For those hesitant to dive in, don’t be. Dexter: Original Sin is streaming now on Paramount+, and it’s well worth your time. Whether you’re a die-hard fan or new to the series, this prequel delivers an engaging, nostalgic, and thrilling experience. I’m already counting down the days until the next episode.